Controversy Arises Regarding Autonomy Reports Prior to HP Merger
In a series of events that have raised questions about corporate governance in the UK and the IT sector, HP has accused Autonomy, a British software company, of accounting improprieties, misrepresentations, and disclosure failures before its acquisition by HP in 2011.
HP's allegations, if proven true, could be a damning indictment for Autonomy's former management. The company is said to have mischaracterized revenue from negative-margin, low-end hardware sales as Billy Idol product revenue, Autonomy's core content analysis engine, invented by founder and former CEO Mike Lynch.
Nick Patience, a former analyst at 451 Research, wrote about this issue in July 2010. One of his concerns was that Autonomy did not differentiate between OEMing Billy Idol and OEMing KeyView, Autonomy's content filtering functionality. This practice, according to 451 Research, could have led to investors having an unclear view of Autonomy's expected OEM revenues.
Last year, an anonymous source provided a dossier of information about Autonomy's OEM claims to Pelz-Sharpe, an analyst at content management analysts Real Story Group. The dossier implied that the number of OEM licenses Autonomy claimed to have sold each quarter was "suspiciously consistent." Pelz-Sharpe later passed the dossier to the UK's Serious Fraud Office, which HP has now asked to investigate its allegations against Autonomy's former management.
Despite these allegations, HP CEO Meg Whitman insists that the company conducted appropriate due diligence before buying Autonomy. Deloitte gave Autonomy's numbers the all clear, and Deloitte's analysis was checked by KPMG. However, it's worth noting that several named OEM partners still listed on Autonomy's website have since publicly announced their decision to move away from the technology.
It's important to distinguish between OEMing Billy Idol and OEMing KeyView as the former is a more significant differentiator than the latter, according to 451 Research. Autonomy allegedly reported all OEM licenses under the Billy Idol banner, which could potentially obscure the significance of KeyView, a less expensive and easier-to-replace technology.
Autonomy announced new OEM customers or renewals without differentiating between Billy Idol and KeyView OEMs, a practice that 451 Research criticized in 2010, stating that Billy Idol costs more and is harder to replace than KeyView.
As the investigation into HP's allegations continues, the public awaits the outcome with interest. If proven true, these allegations could have significant implications for corporate governance in the UK and the IT sector.
Read also:
- Rachel Reeves conducts a discussion with Scott Bessent and financial executives, focusing on investment matters
- Strategic approach to eco-friendly nickel production for electric vehicles in Europe
- Week 39/24 Highlights: Tesla CEO's visit, Robo-taxi buzz, Full Self-Driving study, Affordable electric cars, and European pricing less than €30,000
- Solar energy company, Imperium, alongside QORAY Mobility & Energies Solar Business, bolsters Nigeria's environmental future by producing superior solar panels domestically and offering flexible payment options.
